13 Nov 2026
Thinking on Their Feet: A Tutor's Take On In-Class Writing
by Nick Brown
This fall, there's been a refrain among humanities tutors: Where are all the take-home essays?
In-class essays and class participation have always been important to success in humanities classrooms. But this year, concerns about students using AI at home have led many English and history teachers to make in-class work their primary form of assessment. That change has happened quickly. And as classrooms change, so does how we tutor.
Here's what this shift means for my students and their preparation: the challenges they face, how I get them ready for these new assessments, and what has been gained and lost in this transition.
What are some of the main writing challenges that students come to you with?
I am of the firm belief that writing is effectively just thinking put down on paper. For the most part, when I’m working with students, we are focusing on the beginning blooms of independent thinking.
If you spend time with ninth graders working on a history or English paper, for example, what they are doing instinctively is figuring out how best to echo their teacher’s comments. Because they’ve largely been conditioned to think in terms of the correct answer, they frequently have trouble writing a paper.
My sister used to teach the freshman writing program at Harvard, and she and her colleagues spoke about how the hardest thing they had to deal with in incoming Harvard freshmen was getting them to express their own selves in any meaningful way, rather than echo back arguments they’d read. Putting ideas in contrast with each other was really hard. So that remains an ongoing challenge for students across all levels, but particularly in ninth grade you begin to see it.
How have teachers adjusted their instruction and grading in response to AI?
Already last year, many of the elite schools my students attend had dramatically dropped the number of take-home assignments, and most assessments moved to in-class assignments because of the possibility of cheating at home. Sometimes you’re even seeing research papers where they won’t let students write outside of the classroom.
I think there may be a sort of foresight that if writing is something that is easily duplicated by an artificial system, perhaps what we are seeking in the humanities is an ability to think on one’s feet. There’s a much greater emphasis on orality—on the ability to speak and articulate your thoughts in the classroom environment—and that engagement with class material has become part of the assessment itself. There is the written in-class assessment, but there is also an emphasis on the discussion that leads up to it, and very often the prompts emerge from topics the class has discussed.
If the writing is now happening in class, how has your work shifted? And how are you preparing students for the in-class assessments?
I think muscle development is a good analogy for in-class writing practice. I don't expect instant success, but practice over time leads students to quicken their reflexes, and become simpler and clearer in their writing.
I’ll use The Great Gatsby. We’re looking at the scene where Nick’s envying the possible romances of all the couples walking up Fifth Avenue as he’s lonely in this interim between Gatsby’s parties. The student says, “Okay, Nick's envious of the passion that Gatsby has.” So I'll say, “Great, let’s use Nick's envy of passion as a general idea for how this passage works. Now I want you to take five minutes and look at the specific language of the passage and tell me how it advances that idea. What words does Fitzgerald use? What echoes do you see of other passages in the novel?”
After a few minutes of thinking, the student emerges with his ideas, and we'll try to refine them. Sometimes that entails simply correcting his language—he misunderstands the meaning of a word, say. And sometimes it involves a deeper analysis: Maybe the envy of Gatsby's passion that Nick feels is a manifestation of his own loneliness.
Whatever we come to, I'll have the student practice writing a topic sentence that connects his impressions together. Then we'll write the first few sentences of a practice paragraph that shows how the language in the passage from Gatsby fits into that argument. The goal is both to develop the muscle memory of writing practice and to improve the students' ability to clearly synthesize information into an argumentative first sentence backed up by evidence. Over time, I want to see my students manage this more and more quickly, so that, if we're lucky, we can get through multiple of these practice prompts the night before an in-class essay.
The preparation also comes in the discussions between tests. We’re taking the material they talked about in class and using the fact that we are social animals to make that material more memorable. In the same way that if you see a movie and go out for coffee with somebody afterwards and talk about it, you have a much more vivid impression of the scenes you discussed.
Writing quickly in a classroom on a deadline is an extremely different skill than writing a longer piece at home on your own time. How do you also make sure your students are getting the skills needed for longform and creative writing?
I think we are in an overcorrection right now, and people will see the loss. Many of the parents I work with are looking for essay contests for their kids to enter, to get that experience of long-form writing—to feel what it’s like to parse what you’re trying to say and how you could say it better, and to have your imagination sparked in that process.
So much more of my time now, in history and English tutoring sessions, is devoted to talking aloud about pieces of literature or historical trends. And while I think there’s something lost, I also think that’s extraordinary. We’re not spending all of this time explaining the difference between “there” and “their.” Those mechanical things still matter, but Google Docs fixes them for you in a single click. To be able to talk to these kids about the works they’re reading without the urgent pressure of “we’ve got to write a page tonight” or “we’ve got to edit this and make it as good as it can be,” that matters, too.
The focus becomes much larger; instead of precise sentences, we focus on the scope of a piece of literature—how the scenes of a book or play interact to form a story. Instead of listing historical facts to form a narrative, we can focus on how the same events might tell different stories when we look at them through a different lens. I miss working with students on the precision that comes with at-home writing assignments, but I love the way this new paradigm forces them to practice thinking about and expressing big ideas.